Report 176 -2021- [updated] - Rijal Al Kashi

Not everyone accepted the 2021 findings. A counter-study published in Al-Tahqiq al-Rijali (Issue 9, 2021) argued that Report 176 is a later insertion into al-Kashi’s work by al-Tusi or even later scribes. Their evidence: the report breaks the chronological flow of surrounding entries and uses terminology more common in the 5th century AH.

Hassan ibn Ali ibn Faddal (a real, contested figure – a Fatahite who later returned to Imami orthodoxy). Rijal Al Kashi Report 176 -2021-